NewsMacroFederal Judge Mocks Trump Lawyer's 'Cringe' Argument in D.C. Golf Course Records Battle

Federal Judge Mocks Trump Lawyer's 'Cringe' Argument in D.C. Golf Course Records Battle

Author: Alternet·

Key Takeaways

  • •A federal judge held a hearing into allegations that the Trump administration destroyed documents revealing plans to close a Washington, D.C. golf course despite an existing court injunction.
  • •Whistleblower complaints claim officials are eliminating records tied to Trump's D.C. projects before the incoming Democratic majority can investigate, prompting Democrats to demand preservation and recovery of deleted materials.
  • •Judge Ana Reyes warned she would initiate sanctions or contempt proceedings almost immediately if credible evidence of document destruction surfaced, noting that defying a binding injunction can independently support a contempt case.
  • •Government lawyer Adam R.F. Gustafson argued that voters elected Trump because of his building and real estate experience, an argument the judge mocked and rejected during the hearing.
  • •Reyes challenged the administration's shifting rationales for the closure — first renovation, then safety — securing an admission that renovation remained one reason, and observed that the vast majority of more than 100 people in the courtroom opposed the project.
Federal Judge Mocks Trump Lawyer's 'Cringe' Argument in D.C. Golf Course Records Battle

A federal judge on Friday reportedly mocked government lawyers for offering what observers described as "very cringe" arguments at a hearing examining whether the Trump administration destroyed documents that revealed its plans to close a Washington, D.C. golf course in defiance of a court order. According to courtroom reporters, Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Adam R.F. Gustafson argued, in essence, that President Donald Trump's actions represented the will of the people — a position Judge Ana Reyes flatly rejected.

The hearing grew out of whistleblower complaints alleging that administration officials are destroying records tied to Trump's D.C. vanity projects in anticipation of investigations by the incoming Democratic majority. According to The Independent, Democrats have called on administration officials to "preserve existing records collections and productions," "identify and recover any deleted information," and "suspend any destruction and deletion practices," presumably to prepare for those probes. Such demands reflect a basic mechanic of congressional oversight: an incoming majority's ability to investigate often hinges on records having been preserved in the first place, since documents that no longer exist cannot be compelled or produced.

Reyes, who is presiding over the escalating legal battle over Trump's effort to transform East Potomac Golf Links and a surrounding park into a "World Class, championship-level golf course" — a project local groups have sued to block — issued a blunt warning: "If I find credible evidence of any document destruction, I will start proceedings on sanctions or contempt within a zeptosecond." That warning carries weight beyond the documents themselves: the injunction at the center of the dispute is a binding court order, and defying such an order can independently ground a contempt proceeding.

The friction escalated when the discussion turned to whether Trump had revealed plans to close the park despite the injunction Reyes has issued against such a move. Gustafson advanced an argument that drew "mocking" skepticism from the bench. According to Lawfare senior editor Molly Roberts, Gustafson asserted that "the people elected the president because he's a builder." Reyes made no attempt to hide her incredulity, asking, "People elected him so he could do golf courses in the District?" The government lawyer could only restate the claim, saying again that "people elected him knowing his experience as a builder and success in real estate." Those watching noted that the attempt fell flat. "This is very cringe," appellate attorney Gabriel Malor commented.

It was far from the only pointed exchange. According to reporters in the courtroom, Reyes also pressed on the administration's shifting justifications for closing the park. Trump initially said the closure was needed for renovations, but after the court barred that plan, he claimed it had to be shut down over safety concerns. Did Gustafson, the judge asked, "concede that renovating the golf course is one of the rationales for doing all this?" The lawyer admitted that it was one of the reasons. "The president went to the course this summer," Reyes noted. "If he had seen safety concerns to human individuals, wouldn't he have insisted that something get done immediately?" Court reporter Chris Geidner observed that this was part of a series of questions from Reyes that "have only one answer…bad for him, and he's squirming."

Another uncomfortable moment drew the attention of onlookers. "I take it you are aware that there is some controversy in this design," Reyes asked Gustafson. "People in D.C. are very upset about this design." When the attorney declined to answer directly, the judge asked people in the courtroom to raise their hands if they opposed the project. "Turn around, sir," Reyes told Gustafson, noting that of the more than 100 people in the room, the "vast majority" had their hands up.