NewsMacroPresiding Officer Clarifies VP Sara Duterte Not Accused of Money Laundering

Presiding Officer Clarifies VP Sara Duterte Not Accused of Money Laundering

Author: Bworldonline·

Key Takeaways

  • •Presiding Officer Francis Escudero confirmed that Vice President Sara Duterte-Carpio is not facing a money laundering charge in her impeachment trial, with Anti-Money Laundering Council documents cited only to support allegations of unexplained wealth.
  • •House prosecutor Chel Diokno repeatedly objected to money laundering references during the defense's direct examination, asserting that the articles of impeachment contain no such allegations against the respondent.
  • •The defense presented AML Consulting PH founder and CEO Rainer Dela Fuente as an expert witness to rebut the forensic financial report prepared by lawyer and accountant Alexander Cabrera.
  • •Dela Fuente disclosed he had not been given a copy of Cabrera's report, prompting Diokno and several senator-judges to question how he could critique a document he had not seen.
  • •Senator-judges constrained the scope of the testimony, cautioning that the witness could offer opinions only on the Anti-Money Laundering Act and AMLC documents, and that the court alone decides the weight of the evidence.
Presiding Officer Clarifies VP Sara Duterte Not Accused of Money Laundering

Presiding Officer and Senator-Judge Francis G. Escudero on Thursday reminded the defense team of Vice President (VP) Sara Duterte-Carpio that she is not facing any money laundering charge, clarifying that documents from the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC), the Philippines’ financial intelligence unit, had been cited only as a basis for allegations of unexplained wealth.

Mr. Escudero issued the clarification after House prosecutor Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno challenged the relevance of the direct examination conducted by defense lawyer Mark C. Vinluan.

“He does not need to defend his client against a charge of violation of the AMLC because there is no such charge,” Mr. Escudero told the impeachment court, the Senate tribunal that can remove impeachable officials from office. “Although AMLC was used as a basis to prove… ill-gotten and unexplained wealth, he can go to that at any point in time.”

The defense presented Rainer P. Dela Fuente, founder and chief executive officer of AML Consulting PH, as an expert witness to rebut the forensic financial report prepared by lawyer and accountant Alexander B. Cabrera.

Mr. Diokno objected repeatedly to continued references to money laundering, saying the articles of impeachment contained no such allegations.

“I have seen and read the articles of impeachment a number of times and have not seen any single word that refers to the respondent committing any crime under money laundering,” Mr. Diokno said.

Citing page 14 of the articles of impeachment, Mr. Vinluan noted that the transactions of the vice-presidential couple “may have involved predicate offenses of money laundering.” Predicate offenses are the underlying unlawful acts from which laundered proceeds would arise. Mr. Diokno countered that the phrase did not constitute a charge before the impeachment court.

The presiding officer allowed the examination to proceed, but cautioned that Mr. Dela Fuente’s expertise permitted him to offer opinions only on the Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA), the statute that defines and penalizes money laundering in the Philippines, and the AMLC documents.

Later in the proceedings, Mr. Dela Fuente disclosed that he had not been given a copy of Mr. Cabrera’s report, explaining that he did not need to read the document in order to testify if the report aligned with the law’s provisions. Mr. Diokno and several senator-judges questioned how the lawyer could critique a report he had not seen.

Senator-Judge Francis Pancratius N. Pangilinan questioned the probative value of testimony delivered on a hypothetical basis in an impeachment trial, where the court examines evidence and determines the applicable law.

“I was called upon, your honor, to testify on anti-money laundering standards, and how financial investigation is usually conducted,” Mr. Dela Fuente replied in mixed English and Filipino.

Mr. Vinluan’s questioning had also covered withdrawn articles of impeachment, previous impeachment trials and statements by the friends of the court, among other matters. Senator-Judges Emmanuel Joel J. Villanueva and Rafael “Raffy” T. Tulfo questioned the witness’s competence to discuss those topics.

Under the subpoena issued by the court, Mr. Dela Fuente was to testify “on fundamental legal concepts relating to the Anti-Money Laundering Act as amended, identify documents relevant to his testimony and such other relevant matters.”

“While he may offer an expert opinion within his field as an expert on anti-money laundering, he cannot, in all likelihood, declare the findings of the AMLA to be incorrect or invalid,” Mr. Villanueva said. “Ultimately, it is up to the court to decide the weight of the evidence being presented here.”

Reporting by Francessca S. Abalos, BusinessWorld.