EPA's 'DEF Rule' Comment Period Closes Amid Nearly 200 Submissions Split on Deratement Changes
Key Takeaways
- •The EPA's 'DEF rule' proposal would replace engine deratement penalties with audible and visual signals alerting operators to low or empty DEF supplies.
- •The proposal also shortens emission-related warranty periods tied to the 2027 NOx standards and delays the 'useful life' engine definition to model year 2030.
- •The Truck and Engine Manufacturers Association welcomed derate relief but argued the existing August 2025 guidance is sufficient and called for harmonization with international requirements, especially in the EU.
- •Environmental groups, including California Environmental Voters and the NRDC, criticized the proposal for undermining public health protections and said the 45-day comment period was too short for a technically complex rule.
- •DEF retail trade groups cautioned against eliminating deratements, warning that distorted messaging could lead users to wrongly believe DEF requirements are being repealed.

The public comment period on the federal proposal widely referred to as the "DEF rule" has closed, drawing nearly 200 submissions that span the full range of opinions on possible changes to Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulation. The breadth of the commenters — engine manufacturers, environmental groups, DEF retailers, farm equipment users and motor coach operators — underscores how widely SCR-based emissions control technology has spread since it became standard on U.S. diesel engines, and how many industries have a stake in how strictly its enforcement mechanisms are designed.
The EPA published the proposal in the Federal Register on July 14, following earlier signaling of its intentions, and allowed a relatively short 45-day comment window. That window closed last week, though some comments continued to be posted on the comment website through Tuesday. With the comment period closed, the next formal step in the rulemaking process is for the EPA to review the submissions and issue a final rule, though the agency has not announced a timeline for doing so.
The proposal has come to be known as the DEF (Diesel Exhaust Fluid) rule because, among other goals, it would eliminate or significantly change one widely criticized aspect of DEF use: the "deratement" of an engine, in which the vehicle is slowed when sensors detect that DEF supplies are inadequate or of poor quality.
There have been three EPA actions in a little more than a year aimed at tackling deratements and other DEF-related criticisms: the August 2025 guidance, the March 2026 guidance, and the more formal Federal Register proposal that formed the basis for the recent comments.
Listening and seeing signals
The key Federal Register proposal on deratements — which fall under the category of "inducements" — would replace them with "audible and visual signals." Those signals would alert the user of DEF-mandated equipment, which includes more than just truck engines, to depleting supplies or a fully empty DEF tank, replacing the gradual slowdown of an engine.
The EPA had already loosened some of the earlier deratement requirements in guidance released to engine manufacturers in August 2025, followed by more guidance released in March.
"Guidance" was defined in the March letter as "not (having) the force and effect of law" and seeking to "provide clarity to the public regarding existing requirements under the law or Agency policies."
The August 2025 guidance widened the use of acceptable inducements. The March 2026 guidance opened the door to greater use of NOx sensors rather than the reportedly troublesome Urea Quality Sensors (UQS). But both documents retained the use of deratements, and neither guidance letter to OEMs referenced the "audible and visual signals" that the EPA proposal puts forward as a substitute.
Many of the other specific proposals in the Federal Register document are highly technical, including changes to various aspects of the selective catalytic reduction (SCR) system, which uses DEF as a key component.
Warranties and useful life
The proposal would also shorten the required emission-related warranty periods that were part of the earlier rule creating tighter nitrogen oxide (NOx) standards beginning in model year 2027, and it calls for delaying implementation of the "useful life" definition for engines to model year 2030 rather than 2027.
Another, less technical proposal is the introduction of nonconformance penalties (NCPs) that an engine builder could pay, allowing them to "continue to sell their current products while they complete the development of engines compliant with the model year 2027 standards." Those 2027 standards call for a significant reduction in NOx emissions.
DEF usage is a key component of reduced NOx emissions, which is why many comments from environmental groups criticized the proposal. "Weakening provisions related to useful life requirements, emissions warranties, SCR inducement systems, and nonconformance penalties undermines the EPA's statutory responsibility to protect public health," a group called California Environmental Voters said in its comment submitted to the EPA.
Unsurprisingly, the most complex comments came from manufacturers of the equipment that would be affected by the changes.
DEF does its job
DEF, working inside an SCR system, is considered highly successful at reducing NOx emissions. That success also allows engines to run "hotter" while staying within NOx emission limits, providing greater fuel efficiency — a point made by the Truck and Engine Manufacturers Association (EMA) in its comments.
The EMA, whose members include Cummins (NYSE: CMI), Daimler Truck North America (OTCPK: DTRUY) and PACCAR (NASDAQ: PCAR), said SCR "is highly effective at reducing NOx, enabling manufacturers to optimize combustion to increase engine performance and reduce fuel consumption."
"EMA appreciates that EPA is mitigating the derate impacts on truck and equipment operators in a way that can still ensure that operators maintain the onboard DEF supply necessary for engine efficiency and long-term engine component health," the association said. "We applaud EPA for responding to commercial vehicle and equipment operators who have complained about the real-world impacts of the previous overly-stringing SCR inducement requirements."
August 2025 guidance looks good
But the EMA was lukewarm on the latest proposal. "Regarding the applicability of additional guidance for in-use engines and vehicles, we believe that the existing August Guidance is sufficient," it said.
The association also expressed concern that some changes might be problematic for users of SCR systems outside the trucking sector. The relative standardization of truck technology contrasts with "literally hundreds of nonroad equipment manufacturers producing thousands of different types of nonroad machinery," the EMA said. Many of those applications serve the agricultural sector, which has been among the loudest voices criticizing deratements.
The EMA also called for "global harmonization" with countries that non-truck equipment manufacturers supply. "EPA's regulatory requirements for SCR-related inducements harmonize and align as much as possible with the corollary inducement-related requirements" in other parts of the world, it said, stressing that alignment with the EU is "critical."
The solution, according to the EMA, lies in the guidance from the first EPA action a year ago. An existing rule requiring nonroad engines to move to an "idle condition" after a tank is empty, or four hours after an "SCR fault," should be scrapped in favor of EPA guidance allowing up to 100 hours of operation before deratement begins, "and even then with the derate capped at 50%." Given that the nonroad engine guidance is more than a year old, the EMA warned against "changing course…in a way that abandons the guidance going forward."
The Engine Technology Forum (ETF), previously known as the Diesel Technology Forum, said in its comments that it estimates about half the off-road engine and equipment sector uses SCR/DEF technology.
One concern raised in discussions of the rule is that DEF users could exploit reduced stringency to operate as much as possible without DEF.
Lots of bad info out there
The ETF addressed that indirectly, saying it has had to respond to media reports "seeking to verify casual comments from government officials suggesting that 'we are going to get rid of DEF.'" "This statement has created a false expectation," the group said.
In this video, President Trump says he "terminated" the DEF program (see 4 minutes in), with the video producer's "research" leading him to suggest that the end of DEF is possible.
DEF consumers stretching or reducing their use of the fluid under less stringent deratement rules have drawn the attention of a trio of trade groups whose members sell DEF: the National Association of Truck Stop Operators, the Society of Independent Gasoline Marketers of America and the National Association of Convenience Stores.
In a joint comment to the EPA, the three groups conceded there are legitimate issues of concern. Current deratement requirements "have proven overly punitive and often counter-productive," they said. "Improperly triggered derates – frequently the product of sensor malfunctions – have imposed real costs on drivers and, understandably, eroded goodwill toward SCR systems generally."
But the trio does not want the deratement rule eliminated. The associations praised the August 2025 and March 2026 guidance, writing: "Those measures are directed at the underlying sources of SCR-related challenges, and they should be afforded the requisite time to take effect. Engine manufacturers have only recently begun implementing the guidance across the existing fleet. The full measure of their benefits will not be observable until that process is complete."
They added that they "generally oppose any revisions of the inducement requirements that would ultimately undermine the comprehensive, nationwide system supplying DEF," and that they "support the concerns of manufacturers as they continue to build in strategies to protect their engines against damage, including by using derates."
The groups also voiced concern that messaging around possible changes is becoming distorted, which could ultimately affect supply. "Whichever inducement framework the Agency ultimately adopts will only function properly if drivers understand that DEF remains required as a matter of law and necessary to protect their equipment," they wrote.
Regulations alone will not be enough, they added; success will also depend on "the communications and signals that surround it. The (EPA) should take care to ensure that sensible reforms to the derate schedule are not misperceived by diesel engine users as repealing DEF requirements or encouraging removal of SCR systems."
Buses are interested
The list of commenters includes a notably high number of bus companies, suggesting a coordinated effort within that industry to tell the EPA that deratement has been a particularly large problem for motor coaches.
Trans-Bridge Lines, a motor coach operator in the Northeast, said derates "can create significant safety and operational issues that can ultimately work against that goal." In its comment, the company recalled an incident in which one of its buses "went into derate and was unable to continue operating normally, resulting in a significant traffic backup" — just outside the Lincoln Tunnel connecting New Jersey to Manhattan. The result was a massive traffic jam of cars with idling engines.
"In other words, a system intended to reduce emissions ultimately contributed to a situation that increased emissions while also creating a safety hazard," Trans-Bridge said.
The brevity of the comment period drew criticism from some environmental groups. Atid Kimelman, an attorney with the Natural Resources Defense Council, quoted a legal precedent in saying a 45-day comment period "is…inadequate because the proposed rule is complex and based on scientific or technical data."
"Commenters will be effectively denied their legally guaranteed opportunity to fully respond to EPA's health-harming Proposal and may be unfairly hampered in their ability to preserve potential legal claims in the rulemaking record as the Clean Air Act requires," Kimelman said in the NRDC's comments.
Source: FreightWaves