NewsMacroJustice Department shifts legal strategy in East Potomac Park golf course fight

Justice Department shifts legal strategy in East Potomac Park golf course fight

Author: Alternet·

Key Takeaways

  • •The Justice Department proposed waiving the preliminary injunction hearing and closing written briefing before Thanksgiving, leaving the injunction question to be decided on briefs alone.
  • •The administration wants written arguments completed by Nov. 25 and a ruling before the temporary restraining order expires on Nov. 28, arguing additional witnesses would waste time.
  • •Plaintiffs are seeking more time for investigation and want to subpoena a former contractor to testify about what they were told compared with statements from the DOJ and White House.
  • •Judge Ana Reyes's temporary restraining order keeps the surrounding park open but does not cover the golf course, which remains shut after closing on Nov. 15.
  • •The DOJ's safety justification about a failing seawall emerged only after Trump announced the closure on Truth Social, and Reyes found the Park Service ended the operator's role to carry out Trump's directive to begin the Fazio Design work.
Justice Department shifts legal strategy in East Potomac Park golf course fight

The Justice Department has shifted its legal strategy in the ongoing dispute over the East Potomac Park golf course, which was closed on Nov. 15.

President Donald Trump has sought to take over the golf course, which sits on a man-made island in the middle of the Potomac River that is also home to a park and jogging and cycling trails. Under the redesign Trump outlined, a massive PGA-style golf course would take over the entire island and could be used for various official tournaments. Local residents have relied on the course for generations, drawn by its low cost and its proximity to the city. Because the island is public parkland, the case touches questions that reach beyond golf: whether the government can close and redevelop public recreational space on the strength of a presidential directive, and what approvals are required before such work begins.

Politico's Josh Gerstein posted the Joint Status Report filed on Tuesday, commenting, "DOJ seems to have given up on convincing Reyes on golf course closure, wants to waive hearing on preliminary injunction and close briefing before Thanksgiving. Redesign opponents want to subpoena former contractor to see if feds actually negotiated." The court filing is publicly available via CourtListener. Waiving the hearing, as the DOJ proposes, would leave the injunction question to be decided on written briefs alone rather than through courtroom argument.

The two sides have been battling over how quickly the judge should decide whether the government can close part of East Potomac Park. The judge has issued a temporary restraining order keeping the park open, but it did not cover the golf course. That gap is why the course itself remains shut even as the surrounding park operates under court protection. Over the weekend, the golf course gave away its training clubs for free, as photographer Andrew Leyden reported on X.

Plaintiffs, for their part, say more evidence is needed first and want to bring in contractors to testify about what they were told compared with what the DOJ and White House have said. They are asking the judge to allow more time for investigation, arguing that rushing forward immediately would disrupt witnesses' plans during the holiday week.

The administration wants a ruling immediately. It argues that additional witnesses and lengthy arguments would be a waste of time, that written arguments should be finished by Nov. 25, and that the judge can rule before the restraining order expires on Nov. 28. The government also argued in the filing against the court's previous finding of bad faith by DOJ lawyers. Those dates now frame the next phase of the case: whether Reyes grants the hearing waiver and how she handles the plaintiffs' proposed subpoena of the former contractor will help determine whether the dispute is decided on the existing record or with new testimony.

The DOJ has been accused of inventing a false justification to close the park so that renovations could begin without proper approval, claiming that the island was no longer safe because the seawall was underwater or collapsing. That proposal came only after Trump issued an edict on Truth Social saying that the course would close on Nov. 15 for redevelopment into a championship-level venue. Only after Trump posted the note did the DOJ begin talking about the need to close it because of safety problems. Until then, safety was not part of the discussion.

Judge Ana Reyes also said the government created the problem of there being no operator to handle the daily details of the course. In her TRO, Reyes found that the Park Service ended the organization's operation "so that it could close the Park to effectuate President Trump's directive to begin work on the Fazio Design immediately."