NewsMacroFederal Judge Presses Trump DOJ Over Shifting Story on East Potomac Park Golf Course Closure

Federal Judge Presses Trump DOJ Over Shifting Story on East Potomac Park Golf Course Closure

Author: Alternet·

Key Takeaways

  • •The Justice Department defended in federal court the shutdown of East Potomac Park, arguing the seawall is so dangerous that children could die and the entire island must be closed.
  • •Judge Ana Reyes observed that an Oct. 9 declaration by acting NPS Director Jessica Bowron did not state the seawall posed a risk to human life, even though roughly 30,000 people were on the island for the Marine Corps Marathon in late October.
  • •Trump posted his directive on Oct. 18 and 19, a declaration describing the seawall as falling down and dangerous was filed on Oct. 28, and the Justice Department said on Oct. 30 it was following the directive.
  • •The National Park Service has known about the seawall issue since 2011, with multiple assessments beginning in 2019, and the government is spending $300 million to repair the seawall.
  • •Because the government's safety argument covers the whole island, the dispute puts public access to National Park Service land at stake, not just the golf course.
Federal Judge Presses Trump DOJ Over Shifting Story on East Potomac Park Golf Course Closure

The Justice Department returned to federal court on Friday to defend its position in the battle over the East Potomac Park golf course, which President Donald Trump decided he wanted to take over as part of his ongoing construction projects in Washington, D.C. And because the government's safety argument covers the whole island, the dispute puts public access to National Park Service land — not just the golf course — at stake.

Arguing for the government, Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward and Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Adam R.F. Gustafson maintained that the seawall surrounding the island is so dangerous that children could die, and that the entire island therefore needs to be shut down. Lawfare's Molly Roberts reported the hearing moment by moment on Bluesky.

Judge Ana Reyes found the government's claim confusing, given a declaration submitted on Oct. 9. Declarations are sworn written statements filed with the court in place of live testimony, and in a dispute like this one their exact wording is the evidentiary record — which is why Reyes kept returning to what the documents actually said rather than the government's spoken explanations.

The DOJ's central problem is timing: the Marine Corps Marathon took place at the end of October. The judge noted that roughly 30,000 people were on the island at the time, and that neither the Department of the Interior nor the National Park Service had ever announced that the seawall posed a major hazard.

Gustafson explained that "a well-organized race in broad daylight doesn't present the same risk as children walking in the dark along the deteriorating seawall."

The courtroom laughed. As a national park, the island is not open at night. The walking path and the cycling path are accessible, but a gate goes up each evening at dusk, blocking anyone from reaching the parking lot.

Judge Reyes pressed further: was there anything in the Oct. 9 declaration stating that the seawall was so dangerous that children running around at night could die?

Gustafson began reading from the declaration in technical language about the seawall, including the detail that the sidewalk above it floods twice a day with the tides.

"Tell me in there that she [acting NPS Director Jessica Bowron] says that presents a safety hazard to individuals?" the judge asked.

He held up photos of the flooding. Roberts observed that the judge leaned back in her chair, waiting while Gustafson rambled on about mortar. The two went back and forth over the matter. Complicating the government's position, previous statements had said those areas were being fenced off, and Gustafson began trying to talk over the judge.

Judge Reyes asked again where, in the declaration from the National Park Service director, it says there are potentially hazardous conditions that pose a risk to human life and limb, necessitating closure of the full park. Gustafson struggled to answer, and she asked the question a second time.

Roberts, summarizing the exchange, noted she assumed the judge already knew the answer — or she would not have been hammering it so hard.

"I'm sorry, my mistake," Gustafson admitted. He said the declaration was filed on Oct. 9, which was "well before the decision to close the park" was made.

The judge corrected him, saying his chronology was off: Trump posted on Oct. 18 and 19 that he had issued a directive, and on Oct. 30 the department said it was following it.

"You're carrying out the president's directive, right?" she asked.

"And that's the way government works," the DOJ answered.

"That is the way government works, and that's the point I made for hours [in the last hearing]," Reyes replied. Yet, she said, the DOJ kept telling her she was wrong. "But I guess I wasn't."

A second declaration, filed on Oct. 28, described the seawall as falling down and dangerous. The judge wanted to know what happened between Oct. 9 and Oct. 28 that changed everything. The dates carried weight: Oct. 28 fell after Trump's Oct. 18 and 19 directive posts but before the department's Oct. 30 statement that it was following it. NPS has known about the issue since 2011, she said, and multiple assessments followed beginning in 2019. Yet on Oct. 9, no one described it as a problem.

"Suddenly, on Oct. 28, days after 30k+ people ran around Ohio Drive, it's an emergent situation," the judge said.

The DOJ attributed the timing to limited resources and discretion. That explanation did not persuade Reyes, who noted the government is spending $300 million to repair the seawall.

What the DOJ said in court also does not exactly match what Trump previously said on Truth Social. Reyes quipped, "I'm just trying to figure out which iteration of me not paying attention to the president I'm supposed to go with today."

This article is based on reporting by Alternet.