Democrats Warn Trump Administration to Preserve Records Amid Document Destruction Allegations
Key Takeaways
- •Democratic lawmakers have sent preservation letters to federal agencies including the Justice Department, FBI, DHS, ICE and the Bureau of Prisons since the Nov. 3 election, directing officials to preserve records and disable auto-delete settings on encrypted messaging apps.
- •Rep. Jamie Raskin, the incoming chair of the House Judiciary Committee, asserted there is ample evidence that Trump administration personnel have been systematically destroying, mutilating and concealing government records to evade federal record-keeping laws.
- •Raskin cited a Signal exchange between the FBI's general counsel and an associate of Donald Trump Jr. that appeared configured to automatically delete messages after one week and concerned a health care fraud investigation.
- •White House Counsel Will Scharf told Democratic committee leaders that no official is obliged to comply with their preservation requests because Democrats do not yet chair the committees, while a White House official said the administration complies with all federal record retention laws.
- •Democrats cannot compel records production through subpoenas until committee chairs take power when the new Congress organizes in January, but the preservation letters signal the oversight to come, particularly if Democrats win the White House in 2028.

Although Democrats will not assume control of Congress until January, they are already confronting the White House over the Trump administration's treatment of government records.
Democratic lawmakers and their investigators fear that officials are destroying documents and evading federal records laws while the opportunity remains. Federal records rules generally require agencies to preserve materials documenting official business, including communications created on messaging platforms rather than in formal documents. Since the Nov. 3 election, they have dispatched successive letters to agencies across the government, directing officials to preserve their records and disable auto-delete settings on encrypted messaging apps.
"What I think you're seeing in Congress with these document preservation letters is Congress is drawing a line in the sand and maintaining a record so that if people do go out and destroy records they could potentially be prosecuted in a future administration for obstruction of Congress," Jim Secreto, who served in the Obama White House Counsel's office, told CNN.
In a wave of preservation letters sent to the Justice Department, the FBI, the Department of Homeland Security, ICE and the Bureau of Prisons, Democratic Rep. Jamie Raskin, the incoming chair of the House Judiciary Committee, asserted there is ample evidence that Trump administration personnel have been systematically destroying, mutilating and concealing government records in an apparent effort to evade federal record-keeping laws.
Raskin cited a Signal exchange between the FBI's general counsel and an associate of Donald Trump Jr. that appeared to be configured to automatically delete messages after one week. Signal allows users to set conversations to disappear automatically, a capability that has made messaging apps a recurring point of contention in federal records disputes. The exchange concerned "a potential or ongoing investigation involving an individual wanted by federal authorities on health care fraud and related charges."
"This incident, just one of many that have already been reported to our Committee, is a very serious matter indeed in that it appears that DOJ and FBI officials are openly disregarding federal law in respect to the retention of official government records," Raskin said.
A White House official told CNN, "We comply with all federal record retention laws and regulations."
White House Counsel Will Scharf sent letters earlier this week to the Democratic committee leaders asserting the administration's position that no official is obliged to comply with their requests to preserve or hand over documents and information, given that Democrats do not yet chair the committees. In his letters, Scharf wrote that the purpose behind the Democrats' effort "is not legitimate oversight but to harass and aggrandize."
On Thursday, U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz returned a preservation letter to Raskin, accusing him of weaponizing his investigation without any legislative purpose in mind in order to pursue Trump associates and the administration.
While Democrats cannot yet compel the production of records through subpoenas — a power that shifts to committee chairs once the new Congress organizes in January — the preservation letters amount to a clear signal of what lies ahead, particularly if Democrats go on to win the White House in 2028.