Judge Denies Dismissal in Capitol Guillotine Case, Warns Prosecutors' Theory 'Could Go the Other Way'
Key Takeaways
- •Superior Court Judge Judith Bartnoff denied a defense motion to dismiss the case against Philan Le, rejecting the argument that guillotines are not listed among Washington, D.C.'s prohibited weapons.
- •The judge cautioned that prosecutors must prove at trial that Le intended to use the guillotine to behead or harm another person, noting that an inference drawn from possession alone could go the other way.
- •Le was arrested on Aug. 25 after U.S. Capitol Police spotted his homemade guillotine, which an officer determined had a sharpened metal blade, in the bed of his truck parked near the Library of Congress and the Supreme Court.
- •Prosecutors from U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro's office charged Le with a misdemeanor count of attempted possession of a prohibited weapon, and he has pleaded not guilty.
- •Le's father said his son spent three months building the device in California as a political statement, and legal experts have indicated the charge may be difficult to prove beyond a reasonable doubt.

A District of Columbia judge on Wednesday declined to dismiss the case against a California tattoo artist who transported a 10-foot guillotine to the U.S. Capitol, while signaling that a central argument from prosecutors in the case could backfire, The Washington Post reported.
Superior Court Judge Judith Bartnoff rejected a defense motion to dismiss the case against Philan Le, 36, which contended that guillotines are not on the District's list of prohibited weapons. Denying the motion means the case moves forward rather than ending before trial, with prosecutors still required to meet their burden of proof. At the same time, Bartnoff noted that prosecutors would have to show at trial that Le actually intended to use the device to behead or harm another person.
The case was brought by the office of Jeanine Pirro, the Trump-appointed U.S. attorney for Washington, D.C. Prosecutors have argued that Le's intent to use the guillotine unlawfully can be inferred from the mere fact that he possessed the device. Bartnoff was not yet persuaded by that argument.
“If the only issue is inference, and it's in the back of a truck, conceivably, that inference could go the other way,” Bartnoff said during a hearing on motions in the case. “But until we get to trial, I can't really resolve that.”
Le was arrested on Aug. 25 after U.S. Capitol Police officers spotted his homemade guillotine sitting in the bed of his pickup truck, which he had parked in a permit-only parking space on East Capitol Street near the Library of Congress and the Supreme Court. According to a police affidavit, Le told the arresting officers that he “wasn't there for any specific reason.”
Still, he did not downplay the device. When asked whether it was a working guillotine, Le allegedly said it was “the real deal.” An officer who examined the guillotine also determined that the metal blade was sharpened, according to the affidavit.
Police initially arrested Le for carrying a dangerous weapon, but prosecutors instead charged him with a misdemeanor count of attempted possession of a prohibited weapon, alleging he intended to use the guillotine “unlawfully against another.” Attempt offenses of that kind generally stand or fall on proof of a defendant's intent — the very question Bartnoff flagged as unresolved. Le pleaded not guilty, and a magistrate judge denied prosecutors' request to keep him in jail, saying he had not threatened anyone.
Le's father, Huy Le, told NBC San Diego that his son spent three months constructing the guillotine in the family's backyard in Carlsbad, California, as a political statement, and that he “really meant no harm to anyone.” In videos posted before driving across the country, Le criticized unelected officials and America's “forever wars,” and said he had no intention of harming anyone.
Legal experts told The Washington Post in September that the charge against Le may be difficult to win, because prosecutors will have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he planned to use the device on another person. Bartnoff's comments on Wednesday indicate that the question remains open, and that Pirro's office may need more than the guillotine itself to convict Le at trial. That trial will now be the setting where the inference question is put to the test: whether possession of the device alone can support a finding of intent, or whether — as the judge suggested — that inference could run the other way.