GOP Civil War Erupts as Sen. Cornyn Brands Project 2025 Architect Kevin Roberts 'Irrelevant'
Key Takeaways
- •Sen. John Cornyn publicly attacked Heritage Foundation President Kevin Roberts on X, accusing him of destroying the institution's credibility after Roberts criticized the senator's legacy for thwarting one of President Trump's judicial nominees.
- •Cornyn refuses to return his blue slip for Elliot Gaiser, who leads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel and was nominated to a Dallas-area federal judgeship, arguing the nominee is not from Texas, was not vetted, and that the White House never consulted him.
- •Cornyn is instead backing Steve Fahey, a Fort Worth lawyer with nearly two decades as a federal prosecutor in North Texas, and says he does not want the seat to remain unfilled.
- •Without Cornyn's blue slip, the Judiciary Committee cannot advance Gaiser before Democrats take over the Senate in January, giving the departing senator outsized leverage during the GOP's push to fill remaining court vacancies.
- •A White House official said the administration still expects all of Trump's judicial nominees to be confirmed by the end of the year, though key open questions include whether Gaiser's nomination is withdrawn and whether Fahey's candidacy advances.

Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) delivered a pointed public attack on Kevin Roberts, president of the Heritage Foundation and the architect of Project 2025, after Roberts took a swipe at the senator's "legacy" as he prepares to leave office.
"Kevin, your sycophancy has destroyed the credibility of a once great institution, and in so doing you have made yourself irrelevant," Cornyn posted on X.
Roberts had slammed Cornyn for thwarting one of President Donald Trump's last judicial nominees. "John Cornyn is going out as the Republican Texas Senator who helped get radical leftist James Talarico's agenda started early. What a legacy," Roberts wrote on X, accompanying his post with a screenshot of an Associated Press story about the dispute.
At the center of the clash is the "blue slip" — the approval of a nominee's home-state senators that is needed to advance a court nomination, effectively giving senators veto power over a president's judicial picks. Cornyn told the AP that he has not returned, and does not intend to return, the blue slip for Elliot Gaiser, who heads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel and was tapped earlier this month for a federal judgeship in the Dallas area.
"He's not from Texas. He hasn't been vetted," Cornyn said, adding that better-qualified candidates were available and that the White House never consulted him. Cornyn said he felt bad that Gaiser had been used "as a pawn in this process."
Instead, Cornyn is backing Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey, who spent nearly two decades as a federal prosecutor in North Texas. Cornyn said the White House has asked for information on Fahey, and he stressed that he does not want the seat to remain unfilled.
The Justice Department countered, saying Cornyn's "political antics" are harming the public and the rule of law. Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX), whose staff first reached out to Gaiser about the position the day after the election, said that if the Judiciary Committee does not advance Gaiser, it would effectively hand the seat to Democrats.
The GOP-led Senate is in a mad dash to fill all remaining vacancies on the courts before Democrats take over in January. In that window, a single home-state holdout carries outsized leverage: without Cornyn's blue slip, the Judiciary Committee cannot advance Gaiser before the chamber changes hands.
There is little incentive for Cornyn to play nice. He lost his primary runoff to Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, whom Trump endorsed, and Paxton subsequently lost to Talarico, the first Democrat to win a Senate race in Texas since 1988. Cornyn and Sen. Thom Tillis (R-NC) have since used their seats on the Judiciary Committee to block or slow the confirmation of several of Trump's nominees.
Since the GOP's drubbing in the midterms, Roberts has been taking potshots at Republicans, calling Senate Republican leader John Thune "feckless." The exchange with Cornyn shows how those post-midterm recriminations have spilled into the judicial-confirmation fight itself, with a departing senator and the Heritage president trading public barbs over a stalled pick.
A White House official told the AP that the administration still expects all of Trump's judicial nominees to be confirmed by the end of the year. Cornyn said he does not know whether Gaiser's nomination will be withdrawn. The concrete markers to follow: whether Gaiser's nomination is withdrawn, whether the Judiciary Committee advances him before the January transition, and whether Fahey's file moves in the meantime.