NewsMacroRival GOP Senators Cornyn and Cruz Erupt in Profane Shouting Match on Senate Floor Over Trump Judicial Nominee

Rival GOP Senators Cornyn and Cruz Erupt in Profane Shouting Match on Senate Floor Over Trump Judicial Nominee

Author: Alternet·

Key Takeaways

  • •Senators John Cornyn and Ted Cruz engaged in a heated shouting match on the Senate floor over one of President Trump's judicial nominees, with their voices audible from the press gallery.
  • •The dispute stemmed from Cornyn's refusal to return a blue slip for T. Elliot Gaiser, an Ohio lawyer nominated for a federal judgeship in the Northern District of Texas.
  • •Cornyn said he could not support Gaiser because of multiple procedural problems, including that the nominee is not a Texas lawyer despite being named to one of the state's most important district benches in Dallas.
  • •Cornyn attributed the end of his Senate career to Trump's endorsement of Ken Paxton in the Texas Republican primary, though Paxton went on to lose the general election to James Talarico.
  • •The two senators have never been friends, and their relationship was strained further by the midterm losses, while Cruz's firm Axiom Strategies had worked with Paxton to help him win the primary.
Rival GOP Senators Cornyn and Cruz Erupt in Profane Shouting Match on Senate Floor Over Trump Judicial Nominee

A shouting match between two rival Texas Republican senators broke out on the Senate floor over one of President Donald Trump's judicial nominees, according to new reporting published Wednesday by the Washington Sun.

The confrontation took place the previous afternoon and grew so heated that the voices of Senators John Cornyn (R-TX) and Ted Cruz (R-TX) could be heard "easily" from the press gallery above the largely empty room.

"I don't find you credible. I'm mad at you!" Cornyn told Cruz, his voice booming across the chamber, the Sun reported. Cornyn then declared that he was upset at someone "for ending my career!" Reporters could not make out whether that remark was directed at Cruz or at Trump, whose endorsement of Ken Paxton in the Texas Senate Republican primary effectively ended that career. Cruz's response, inaudible to the Sun's reporters, set Cornyn off again, drawing the shout, "Oh, that's bulls——!" Cornyn then waved Cruz off with his hand and stomped away to the Democratic side of the aisle.

According to the Sun, the clash stemmed from Cornyn's refusal to return a blue slip for T. Elliot Gaiser, blocking the conservative Ohio lawyer from a federal judgeship for the Northern District of Texas. The blue slip itself is a long-standing feature of Senate Judiciary Committee practice: the panel asks a judicial nominee's two home-state senators to sign slips signaling their approval or objection, and for district-court seats — lifetime appointments to the federal bench — a home-state senator's refusal to return one has historically been among the surest ways to stall a nomination, with each committee chairman deciding how strictly to honor the tradition. Cornyn, a former judge himself, later told the Sun that Cruz is "not happy that the White House has made it impossible for me to support their nominee Elliot Gaiser." Cornyn said he could not support Gaiser due to "a lot of different process fouls, but one of the fundamental issues is he's not even a Texas lawyer, and I don't know why a Texas senator would agree to a nomination of somebody from Ohio for one of the most important district benches in the state, in Dallas."

The Sun reported that the two senators have never been friends, and their difficult relationship was strained further by the heavy losses Texas Republicans suffered in this year's midterm elections. Cruz had remained publicly neutral in Cornyn's bitter primary race, only to watch Paxton lose to James Talarico and drive a blue wave across the state — an outcome Cornyn had predicted — leaving Cruz as the last statewide elected Republican in the upcoming term. Cruz's political operation, Axiom Strategies, had in the meantime worked with Paxton and helped him win the primary.

"I just knew he was never one of my supporters," Cornyn said of Cruz.

Asked why Cornyn was so upset, Cruz replied: "You'd have to ask him."