CLARITY Act Unlikely to Pass Before 2027, Top Crypto Lawmakers Warn
Key Takeaways
- •House Financial Services Committee Chairman French Hill said the CLARITY Act's chances of passage during the lame-duck session are low, and he plans to pitch market structure legislation again when the new Congress convenes in January.
- •The Senate rejected the CLARITY Act on Sept. 15 with a 49-50 procedural vote that fell short of the required 60 votes, and the bill will expire on Jan. 3 unless the lame-duck session revives it.
- •The House passed the legislation 294-134 in July 2025 with support from 78 Democrats, a bipartisan base Hill expects to continue as the bill will need it to clear the Senate's procedural threshold.
- •House Democrats are discussing a market structure bill built on Rep. Maxine Waters' Crypto Investor and Consumer Bill of Rights, which would assign the SEC a bigger role and the CFTC a smaller one.
- •The GENIUS Act stablecoin law takes effect on Jan. 18, 2027, and six senators have asked Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent to extend a safe harbor to stablecoin issuers in states with rules already in place.

House Financial Services Committee Chairman French Hill said the CLARITY Act is unlikely to become law before the end of the year, leaving the crypto market structure bill to a new Congress that Democrats will control.
The House-passed bill would divide oversight of digital asset markets between the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the core jurisdictional question the legislation was designed to resolve.
Hill, an Arkansas Republican, spoke Thursday at the Capitol Crypto Forum in Washington. "We never give up hope in a lame duck, but it is lame, and therefore the chances are not high," he said. He added that he plans to make market structure legislation his pitch when the next Congress convenes in January.
"I regret that it was not something we could get done effectively in this Congress," Hill said. He noted that 78 Democrats voted for the CLARITY Act in the House and said he expects that support to continue — the kind of bipartisan base the bill will need to clear the Senate's procedural threshold.
Hill also called it encouraging that Rep. Maxine Waters, the committee's top Democrat, circulated a memo to House Democrats naming digital asset market structure as a topic she intends to work on if she becomes chair.
Senate floor time is running out
Sen. Bernie Moreno, the CLARITY Act's lead sponsor in the Senate, told the same forum there is "no scenario" in which crypto legislation passes the chamber during the lame-duck session. According to The Hill, funding the government, the National Defense Authorization Act and the farm bill will take priority, and the session is set to end in less than a month.
The Senate blocked the CLARITY Act on Sept. 15, voting 49-50 on a procedural motion that needed 60 votes. All Democrats and four Republicans opposed it, CBS News reported. Sen. Thom Tillis entered a motion to reconsider, which keeps the option of another vote alive, but the bill dies when this Congress ends on Jan. 3 unless the lame-duck session revives it. Federal legislation does not carry over between Congresses, so anything not passed by Jan. 3 would have to be reintroduced from scratch in the next Congress — under Democratic control of both chambers.
The House passed the legislation 294-134 in July 2025. President Donald Trump urged lawmakers in August to send it to his desk, but Democrats objected that its ethics provisions did not go far enough to address his potential conflicts of interest in crypto. Regulators have since moved ahead on their own, including with an SEC exemption for tokenized stocks.
Democrats prepare to take over
The industry is now scrambling to repair its relationship with Democrats, Politico reported Thursday. The industry spent $55 million trying to defeat Sen.-elect Sherrod Brown of Ohio, who won his seat back, and Democrats are set to retake both the House and Senate in January.
Sen. Ruben Gallego, a crypto-friendly Arizona Democrat who spent months negotiating the Senate bill, gave Politico's Jasper Goodman a blunt assessment of the industry's political prospects. "They're f***ed," Gallego said, according to a post from journalist Eleanor Terrett.
Terrett has reported that House Democrats are discussing turning Waters' Crypto Investor and Consumer Bill of Rights into their own market structure bill. The proposal would give the SEC a bigger role and the CFTC a smaller one, and she cited three industry sources who have spoken with Democratic staffers. Republicans have called it a "messaging bill."
GENIUS Act deadline approaches
Hill used the forum to warn about the gap between the two bills. Trump signed the GENIUS Act, the stablecoin law, in July 2025, but market structure legislation never followed. Hill said the SEC and CFTC cannot fill the gap with exemptive relief alone, because it does not give the market lasting legal certainty.
"When you pass GENIUS without CLARITY, it's like passing and creating a cell phone, but you have no cell network," Hill said.
The stablecoin law takes effect on Jan. 18, 2027, and Treasury is still working on its rules — meaning stablecoin issuers will be operating under new federal requirements while the market structure question CLARITY was written to answer remains unresolved. Terrett reported Wednesday that Sens. Cynthia Lummis and Kirsten Gillibrand, joined by four other senators, asked Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent to extend a safe harbor to stablecoin issuers in states with rules in place before Jan. 18, 2028. The near-term markers are whether the Senate acts on Tillis' motion to reconsider before the session ends, how Treasury responds to the safe harbor request, and what form Democrats' market structure draft takes when the new Congress convenes in January.
This article first appeared on Bitcoin Magazine and is written by Micah Zimmerman.