CLARITY Act Remains Blocked in Senate as SEC and CFTC Nominees Await Confirmation
Key Takeaways
- •The CLARITY Act failed a Senate procedural vote on September 15 with 49 votes in favor and 50 against, falling short of the 60 votes required to proceed.
- •Senator Cynthia Lummis accused Democrats on November 15 of opposing the bill despite it containing the mandatory SEC registration process for token issuances they had demanded.
- •President Trump sent four nominees to the Senate on November 12 — Kristin Johnson and Steven Levine for the SEC and Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland for the CFTC — all of whom require confirmation, with no hearing yet scheduled for the CFTC picks.
- •Democrats won both houses of Congress in the November 3 midterms, and CLARITY Act negotiations will continue under new leadership when Congress reconvenes on January 3, 2027.
- •The Senate passed a bipartisan energy permitting bill 73-25 on November 9 that would grant bitcoin mining fast-track permits while shifting more grid upgrade costs to large data centers.

The CLARITY Act remains blocked after failing to advance in the Senate, leaving supporters with very little time for another attempt before the legislative session ends. Meanwhile, Congress must confirm four nominees to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) ahead of a leadership change in January.
Lummis Criticizes Democrats Over Stalled Market Structure Bill
On November 15, Senator Cynthia Lummis criticized Democrats for opposing the cryptocurrency market structure bill. According to her, Democrats wanted a registration mechanism at the SEC for token issuance but voted against legislation that would have provided one.
In a post on X, Lummis wrote:
"Democrats demanded a mandatory SEC front door so crypto projects have to certify what they're selling before they sell it to the public. The Clarity Act requires it, but Democrats voted against this protection for consumers."
— Senator Cynthia Lummis (@SenLummis) November 15, 2026
The CLARITY Act failed a procedural vote in the Senate on September 15, drawing 49 votes in favor and 50 against. Supporters needed 60 votes to proceed.
Why the CLARITY Act Remains Blocked
The legislation would place digital asset oversight jointly under the SEC and the CFTC, setting out regulation that covers token issuance and trading platforms. Advocates view these provisions as clarifications to federal crypto law.
In July 2025, the House passed the CLARITY Act 294 to 134, with 78 Democratic votes in favor. That split has persisted in the Senate. Senator Tillis voted differently and introduced a motion to reconsider the procedural failure, which may leave an option to revive the effort. However, neither step schedules a vote nor assures supporters of another attempt this session.
Ahead of the vote, Lummis introduced a new version of the CLARITY Act addressing decentralized finance (DeFi) registration and Bank Secrecy Act requirements, while also clarifying its applicability to spot digital commodity transactions. The revision did not bring the votes needed to open debate.
On November 15, Lummis criticized the registration process Democrats proposed to use at the SEC, stating that they had rejected the bill's safeguard. Democrats have also pushed for stricter ethics rules and custody regulations.
According to Digital Chamber CEO Cody Carbone, there is little chance of any legislative effort before the session finishes, because other priorities take precedence over legislative time. No date has been set for further discussion of the CLARITY Act.
Trump Sends Four SEC and CFTC Picks to Senate
President Donald Trump sent four nominations to the Senate on November 12: Kristin Johnson and Steven Levine for the SEC, and Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland for the CFTC. The slate includes nominees from both parties and will fill vacancies at both organizations.
Paul Atkins chairs the SEC alongside Commissioner Mark Uyeda. Mike Selig chairs the CFTC, where he serves as its only member. If confirmed, the four would expand the ranks of the same two agencies the CLARITY Act would task with digital asset oversight — the CFTC currently has a single member.
Johnson and Levine had a hearing before the Senate Banking Committee on November 19. No hearing has been announced for the CFTC nominees, and all four require Senate confirmation.
Kristin Smith, interim CEO of the Blockchain Association, described the rest of the year's schedule as packed. She said the regulatory bodies are busy making rules for digital assets even without passage of the CLARITY Act.
What Changes When Democrats Take Congress
Democrats captured both houses of Congress in the midterm elections held on November 3. The new majorities begin their work after Congress reconvenes on January 3, 2027, meaning the CLARITY Act negotiation process will continue under new leadership in both chambers.
A number of Democrats want enhanced safety measures. Proposed bills have addressed custody requirements, reserve disclosure, and conflicts involving public officials. There is no renewed bipartisan agreement at the moment.
The crypto industry has discussed smaller agreements focused on tax policies, stablecoin revenues, and anti-money laundering protections. According to Ryan Eagan of the Crypto Council for Innovation, policymakers can attach such proposals to bills that must pass Congress.
Energy permitting and data centers present another legislative track. The Senate passed a bipartisan permitting bill 73 to 25 on November 9. The bill seeks quicker permitting procedures and would shift more grid upgrade expenses to big data centers. Under parts of the proposal, bitcoin mining would receive fast-track permits but face higher infrastructure fees. The proposal still needs further action from Congress.
The items to watch from here are concrete: whether Senator Tillis's motion to reconsider produces a scheduled vote, whether the CFTC nominees receive a hearing, and whether any of the four picks are confirmed before the new Congress convenes on January 3.
For now, the CLARITY Act remains unresolved.