CFTC's Selig Outlines Two Routes to the US Market for Hyperliquid as Wall Street Warns on Perps
Key Takeaways
- •CFTC Chairman Michael Selig said crypto derivatives platforms can reach US retail traders either by securing their own exchange licenses or by partnering with an existing licensed operator, and neither route exempts them from complying with current US derivatives regulations.
- •Backpack has obtained FCM, DCM, and DCO registrations to operate a full US derivatives business, while Intercontinental Exchange is pursuing a partnership with Trade[XYZ] to launch a US venue built on a permissioned version of Hyperliquid's HIP-3 technology that still requires regulatory approval.
- •A Stanford-Columbia study estimated that mostly retail traders using Hyperliquid's front end lost about $1.11 billion across ten contracts from March 2025 to June 2026, while market makers gained $208 million, with trading fees accounting for $725 million of the losses.
- •CME Group and an organization associated with Cboe Global Markets and Citadel Securities have taken their objections to the CFTC's treatment of perpetual futures to court, arguing the products, which have no expiry and rely on funding payments, resemble swaps.
- •Hyperliquid's HYPE token rose from $78 to $94 after the ICE–Trade[XYZ] partnership was announced on October 29, amid reported Wall Street interest in blockchain-based derivatives.

CFTC Chairman Michael Selig says cryptocurrency derivatives platforms such as Hyperliquid have two routes for gaining access to the US retail market: securing their own exchange licenses or teaming up with an existing licensed operator. Both routes require compliance with US derivatives regulations, including safeguards for investors. The CFTC regulates futures and derivatives markets in the United States, making it the agency both routes must satisfy. Hyperliquid itself has not yet received approval to serve US retail traders.
Two doors into the US market
Speaking at Thursday's Capitol Crypto Forum, Selig outlined two routes for onchain trading platforms to enter the US market: obtaining their own exchange licenses or partnering with an already licensed exchange, according to reports. In no scenario, however, do these routes exempt platforms from complying with the regulations already in force.
In a statement released on November 16, Selig specified regulatory requirements related to anti-money laundering, customer protection and fund segregation, market surveillance, financial resources, and risk management.
The CFTC had already opened the door to perpetual futures through a May policy allowing case-by-case reviews, and the agency has approved a bitcoin-linked perpetual futures contract.
Backpack's full-stack licenses versus ICE's planned venue
Backpack is taking the exchange license route, having secured three authorizations: futures commission merchant (FCM), designated contract market (DCM), and derivatives clearing organization (DCO). Within the CFTC's framework, those registrations map to the core functions of a US derivatives operation: the DCM designation covers the venue where contracts trade, the DCO handles clearing, and the FCM registration allows the firm to accept customer orders and hold customer funds. Its FCM approval came on November 18, two days after the other two. Backpack plans to connect US traders with global liquidity through a single order book, although trading has not yet been confirmed to have started.
Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), by contrast, has chosen the partnership route. Under its partnership with Trade[XYZ], the company plans to launch a new trading venue in the US that would require identity verification and use a permissioned version of Hyperliquid's HIP-3 technology — the protocol's framework for deploying perpetual markets onchain. The venture still needs regulatory approval, according to Galaxy Research.
Billionaire investor Stan Druckenmiller has backed Trade[XYZ], a move that, according to Cryptopolitan, reflects Wall Street's growing interest in blockchain-based derivatives. After the ICE–Trade[XYZ] partnership was announced on October 29, the value of Hyperliquid's HYPE token rose from $78 to $94.
Separate order books and the liquidity question
ICE's proposed US venue is set to operate independently of Hyperliquid's current markets. According to Galaxy Research, Trade[XYZ]'s HIP-3 markets have already processed more than $650 billion in trading volume. The proposed US venue, however, would need to build its own pool of buyers and sellers.
Separate markets could create problems during sudden price swings, particularly over weekends. Prices might differ between the two venues, making it harder for traders to manage risk.
The implications extend beyond cryptocurrencies. Talos research shows perpetual contracts expanding into equities, commodities, and stock indices.
Why Wall Street is fighting the futures label
Efforts to introduce perpetual futures contracts in the US have sparked a legal battle over how the products should be regulated. According to a Reuters report, CME Group and an organization associated with Cboe Global Markets and Citadel Securities have taken their complaints against the CFTC to court.
Unlike traditional futures, perpetual contracts have no expiry date and rely on recurring funding payments. Critics argue that these features make them more like swaps, which face different regulatory requirements, and warn that treating perpetuals as futures could weaken safeguards against excessive leverage and counterparty risk.
Selig disagrees. He argues that funding payments are similar to margin adjustments in traditional futures. The legal dispute could determine how US regulators oversee both crypto-linked and stock-linked perpetual contracts.
Who actually loses on perps
Trading data already illustrates the risks. A Stanford-Columbia study examined ten Hyperliquid contracts from March 2025 to June 2026. Traders using the platform's front end, considered mostly retail, recorded an estimated $1.11 billion in losses, while market makers gained $208 million. Trading fees accounted for $725 million of the retail group's losses. The researchers measured trading performance using prices two hours after each transaction, and the figures do not represent total realized retail losses.
The broader market faces similar risks. The study cited $61.7 trillion in global crypto-perpetuals trading volume in 2025 and nearly $150 billion in reported liquidations, with more than $19 billion of that occurring on October 10, 2025, alone — the largest single-day liquidation total on record for crypto markets. A BIS analysis also highlights credit and liquidity risks.
Bringing offshore trading under US supervision could strengthen investor protections. However, keeping trading venues separate could divide liquidity and raise costs for brokers and investors.