Burnham Refuses to Rule Out More Borrowing, Blames Tories for Debt Crisis
Key Takeaways
- •Prime Minister Andy Burnham refused to rule out additional borrowing or tax rises to fund government spending plans during his first PMQs.
- •Gilt yields have pushed UK government borrowing costs to their highest levels in nearly two decades.
- •Burnham said Chancellor John Healey would adhere to the fiscal rules assessed by the Office for Budget Responsibility.
- •Economists warn higher gilt yields make Budget tax hikes more likely and could halve the Chancellor's fiscal headroom depending on OBR judgments in October.
- •Burnham confirmed a commitment to reach 3 per cent of GDP on defence by 2030, with a full spending plan due by mid-next year.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham has refused to rule out additional borrowing and tax rises to fund his government's spending plans, blaming the UK's vulnerability to a global bond rout on the previous Conservative government.
Appearing at his first Prime Minister's Questions, Burnham said the UK's spiralling debt costs — which have reached near two-decade highs in recent days — were the result of "exposure" left behind by the Conservatives. Gilt yields, which determine the interest rate the government pays when it borrows, have climbed in recent sessions, raising the cost of servicing the UK's debt pile and tightening the fiscal constraint facing the new Chancellor.
When challenged by Tory leader Kemi Badenoch over whether further tax increases or borrowing could follow, the Prime Minister declined to rule either out, saying only that the government was already "taking the action needed to get debt down". He said Chancellor John Healey would adhere to the fiscal rules and pledged to lead a government "grounded in fiscal responsibility". Those rules — which govern how much the government can borrow and over what timeframe debt must be falling — are assessed independently by the Office for Budget Responsibility, whose judgments determine how much fiscal headroom a chancellor has at each fiscal event.
"I've already indicated my first moves were to cut tax, but I'm not going to do what any prime minister has done and write the Budget here," Burnham said, referring to his early decisions to cut business rates for certain sectors and remove VAT on household energy bills.
"I took a deliberate decision to set an early date for the Budget so that we reduce the period for prolonged speculation of the kind that she is wanting us to indulge in today," he added.
Burnham went on to accuse the Tories of presiding over "14 years of stagnant growth" and "14 years of debt rising", before turning on shadow chancellor Andrew Griffith for his role as a Treasury minister when Liz Truss and Kwasi Kwarteng delivered the mini-budget. The 2022 mini-budget, which contained large unfunded tax cuts, triggered a sharp sell-off in gilts and a liquidity crisis in pension funds, and its memory continues to shape how markets and opposition politicians respond to signs of fiscal loosening.
Burnham labelled 'spendthrift'
Badenoch countered that markets were worried about a "spendthrift people-pleaser" who "wants to say yes to everyone but cannot tell us where the money is coming from".
Burnham's debut PMQs was overshadowed by rising gilt yields, which have pushed government borrowing costs to their highest levels in nearly 20 years.
Economists have warned that, as a result of higher gilt yields, Healey is now more likely to announce tax hikes at the Budget. Depending on judgments taken by the Office for Budget Responsibility in October, the increased costs could halve the fiscal headroom. The Budget date — fixed early by Burnham, as he noted — will therefore be the first full test of whether the government can balance its spending ambitions against market pressure on borrowing costs.
Burnham's attacks on the Tories' record in office came despite his stated commitment to ending political "point scoring". A spokesman for the Prime Minister said he would continue to point out "where they disagree" on policy, but insisted he was willing to work with the opposition leader on welfare reform for young people out of work and on social care.
The session also featured a rebuke from defence committee chair Tan Dhesi, who warned that "vibes alone are not going to be good enough" to protect the UK.
"Rather than kick the can down the road, will the PM urgently commit to a pathway to reaching three per cent of GDP on defence by 2030 which as his Chancellor rightly noted is critical to keep our country safe?" Dhesi asked. The NATO alliance's current benchmark for members is two per cent of GDP on defence, and the UK government has previously committed to moving to 2.5 per cent, making the 3 per cent-by-2030 goal a further step up.
Burnham responded that he had "made that commitment", adding that a full plan for raising defence expenditure would be set out by the middle of next year.