Acquittal in Ethereum's $25 Million MEV Case Leaves BlackRock Staking Risk Unresolved
Key Takeaways
- •BlackRock's staked Ether ETF earns a share of payments traders make to prioritize their Ethereum transactions, income that flows through staking economics.
- •Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, both MIT-educated, were charged by the Department of Justice in May 2024 with wire fraud and money laundering in what prosecutors called the first criminal case involving Ethereum blockchain manipulation.
- •The April 2023 incident extracted roughly $25 million from three traders whose transactions executed in a different order than the brothers' validator had signed.
- •The acquittal rested on prosecutors' inability to prove that signing a block constituted a binding promise to publish trades in a specific order, not on a finding that trading-order income is lawful.
- •Whether profiting from transaction ordering is itself unlawful remains unresolved, leaving open the staking-program disruption risk described in BlackRock's prospectus.

BlackRock's staked Ether exchange-traded fund earns a share of what traders pay to get one Ethereum transaction ahead of another. That income stream is why the asset manager flagged the criminal prosecution of brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno in its prospectus, warning that if profiting from the order of trades were found unlawful, its staking program could be disrupted.
The brothers' acquittal has left that risk unresolved, because the fraud case turned on a narrower question than the legality of trading-order income itself. An acquittal establishes only that prosecutors did not prove the charges as brought; it is not a finding that the conduct was lawful. Three traders lost about $25 million when their trades ran in a different order from the one the brothers' validator had signed.
The case behind the prospectus warning
The Peraire-Bueno brothers were charged by the United States Department of Justice in May 2024 with wire fraud and money laundering offenses stemming from an April 2023 episode in which roughly $25 million was extracted from Ethereum traders through manipulation of transaction ordering. Both brothers were educated at MIT, and federal prosecutors described the indictment as the first-ever criminal case involving the manipulation of the Ethereum blockchain.
How trade ordering becomes income
The position of a transaction within an Ethereum block can carry economic value, a phenomenon known as maximal extractable value (MEV). Traders may pay priority fees or builder tips so that validators or block builders place their transactions ahead of competing ones. Since Ethereum's September 2022 transition to proof-of-stake, a large share of this activity has run through MEV-boost, an out-of-protocol marketplace in which specialized block builders propose complete blocks to validators through intermediary services known as relays. Those payments accrue to the parties that control transaction ordering, which places order-dependent income inside staking economics — the channel through which a fund like BlackRock's earns a share of it.
What prosecutors had to prove
To prove fraud, prosecutors had to show that signing the proposed block amounted to a promise to publish the trades in that order. They could not establish what terms the brothers had accepted from the relay service that sent them the block, a gap that separated the act of signing from any binding commitment to a specific ordering. The structure of MEV-boost helps explain that gap: with the marketplace operating outside Ethereum's protocol, what a validator has agreed to with a relay is not fixed by the network itself.
Why BlackRock's staking agreement matters
That gap in the evidence helps explain the value of a provision in BlackRock's own staking agreement. When the fund wants validators to maintain controls for screening sanctioned wallets, Coinbase must obtain a binding commitment from them. If a validator breaks that promise, the fund can point to a duty the validator accepted and ask Coinbase to enforce it — the same element prosecutors could not establish in the criminal case.
Because the verdict hinged on the narrower evidentiary question, it did not resolve whether profiting from the order of trades is itself unlawful — the scenario BlackRock's prospectus warned could disrupt its staking program. That question remains open, and with it the risk the fund's prospectus describes.