Bill Kristol urges next Congress to use full constitutional powers to restrain Trump
Key Takeaways
- •Bill Kristol called on the next Congress to make the fundamental choice to exercise its full constitutional powers to rein in President Trump, arguing that Trump can do considerably more damage with more than two years left in office.
- •Trump is scheduled to attend the first Quad meeting of his second term with the leaders of Australia, India, and Japan in the Philippines, with the main event being the APEC meeting in Shenzhen, where he will meet Xi Jinping for the third time this year and hold a three-way meeting with Xi and Vladimir Putin.
- •Kristol pointed to Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution, which gives Congress authority over national defense, foreign commerce, tariff-related taxes and duties, and declarations of war, all of which bear directly on trade and foreign affairs.
- •A senior administration official said the chips scandal with China should have no bearing on the trip and belongs to the interagency process, while Kristol argued such national security issues should be handled by Congress through lawmaking rather than merely investigating.
- •Kristol wrote that the 120th Congress could become the most consequential Congress controlled by a party that does not hold the presidency since the post-Watergate 94th Congress of 1975–1977, and that the current 119th Congress could partially redeem itself during its lame-duck session.

As President Donald Trump left Washington on Monday for a four-day visit to Asia, Bill Kristol urged the next Congress to rein in the president by exercising its full constitutional authority.
In a piece for The Bulwark, Kristol — who served as chief of staff to Vice President Dan Quayle under President George H.W. Bush and serves as editor-at-large of The Bulwark — called on Congress to make the “fundamental and, yes, in a way radical, choice to exercise your full constitutional powers.”
Voters did everything they could in this month’s midterm elections to contain Trump, Kristol wrote. Midterms, held halfway through a presidential term, decide all 435 House seats and roughly a third of the Senate, with the new Congress seated in January. But Trump remains president of the United States, with more than two years left in office, and “he can do a whole lot more damage.”
Kristol wrote that proposals for Congress to use its substantial powers are met with “eye-rolls and snickers from the sophisticated set,” who apparently view Congress’s role as watching and commenting rather than acting.
He cited Rep. Gregory Meeks of New York, the top Democrat on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, who said of Trump’s Asia trip, “We’re going to have a very close eye on it.”
On Tuesday, Trump is scheduled to attend the first Quad meeting of his second term — formally the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue — with the leaders of Australia, India and Japan, in the Philippines. Kristol wrote that Trump is less interested in meeting with friendly democracies, however. The main event is the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) meeting in Shenzhen, China, where Trump will meet Xi Jinping for the third time this year and hold a three-way meeting with Xi and Vladimir Putin. In Kristol’s words, it is a meeting of “two dictators and a would-be one.”
Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution gives Congress the power to “provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States” and “to regulate Commerce with foreign Nations.” The same section also empowers lawmakers to lay taxes, duties and imposts — the levers of tariff policy — and to declare war, authorities that bear directly on trade and foreign affairs.
Kristol described the Trump administration as corrupt, incompetent and malevolent, and said it is even more dangerous because major private-sector organizations are cooperating with it.
He wrote that leaders of the next Congress can make clear to America’s allies and adversaries that the president is not the only representative of the United States, and that Congress will set policy according to the country’s interests and principles.
A senior administration official told reporters over the weekend that the chips scandal with China “should not really have any bearing on the trip,” calling it a matter for the administration’s “interagency process.” Kristol argued that such national security issues should be handled by Congress, which should be making laws rather than merely investigating lawlessness.
The 120th Congress could become the most consequential Congress controlled by a party that does not hold the presidency since the post-Watergate 94th Congress of 1975–1977, Kristol wrote. He added that even the current 119th Congress could partially redeem itself by acting during its lame-duck session, the window between Election Day and the seating of the new Congress.
“There’s no time like the present” for Congress to fulfill its constitutional duties and do the right thing, Kristol concluded. For readers tracking the debate over congressional authority, the immediate checkpoints are the 119th Congress’s lame-duck session and the seating of the 120th Congress in January.
Source: Alternet