NewsMacroAsia's Green Shift Turns Pragmatic as Energy Security Takes Priority, Says Moody's Sustainable Finance Chief

Asia's Green Shift Turns Pragmatic as Energy Security Takes Priority, Says Moody's Sustainable Finance Chief

Author: Fortune Crypto·

Key Takeaways

  • •Geopolitical shocks, including the 2022 Ukraine war and this year's closure of the Strait of Hormuz following U.S. strikes on Iran, have exposed Asia's reliance on Middle Eastern energy supplies.
  • •Japan announced plans to build up to five nuclear reactors in the 2040s and 14 more in the 2050s, while Singapore committed S$800 million to low-carbon research targeting emissions of 45-50 million tonnes of CO2 by 2035.
  • •China, Japan, South Korea, and Indonesia have all increased coal-fired capacity since 2020 despite decarbonization pledges, and the Philippines plans to boost coal output after declaring a national energy crisis.
  • •The EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, operational since January, requires Asian steel, aluminium, and cement exporters to account for their carbon intensity to access the EU market.
  • •The United Nations said the world has failed to limit warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius, and last year's record monsoon season is driving greater investment in climate resilience across under-insured parts of Asia.
Asia's Green Shift Turns Pragmatic as Energy Security Takes Priority, Says Moody's Sustainable Finance Chief

An "erosion of multilateralism" is reshaping Asia's sustainability agenda, as governments across the region prioritize energy security and supply chain resilience over what Rahul Ghosh, global head of sustainable finance and emerging markets at Moody's Ratings, calls "virtue signalling."

"Ten years ago, the world was aligning around consistent climate policies, but now we're starting to see a bit of divergence," Ghosh says. Countries are instead pursuing what he describes as a "pragmatic transition"—one that balances sustainability against energy security and economic affordability, typically by keeping traditional fossil fuels in the energy mix.

Geopolitical conflict has driven much of this reassessment of the green transition. Russia's invasion of Ukraine in 2022 sent fuel prices soaring, triggering an energy crisis across much of the developing world. More recently, February's U.S. strikes on Iran and the resulting closure of the Strait of Hormuz cut Asia's oil and gas supplies, underscoring for the region's governments just how dependent they remain on energy from a volatile Middle East. The Strait of Hormuz is one of the world's most important oil chokepoints, handling a large share of globally traded crude, which is why its closure rippled so quickly through Asian supply chains.

In response, Asian governments are pursuing a range of options to reduce their reliance on Middle Eastern energy: investing more heavily in renewable energy and nuclear power, finding alternative oil and gas suppliers such as the U.S., and—perhaps most concerningly—returning to coal power generation. The stakes are high for global climate goals: Asia accounts for the majority of the world's energy-related carbon emissions, so the pace and direction of its transition will heavily shape whether global targets are met.

On Aug. 25, Japan unveiled detailed plans to accelerate its green transformation, including building up to five nuclear reactors in the 2040s and 14 more in the 2050s. "The Government of Japan is now undertaking various measures as it makes all efforts to ensure a stable supply of energy and critical goods to safeguard the lives and livelihoods of the Japanese people," Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi said during a press conference in April. "Fuel supply shortages and supply-chain disruptions in Asia…result in major negative societal and economic impacts for Japan."

Singapore has committed 800 million Singapore dollars ($631 million) to supporting research on low-carbon energy generation and decarbonisation technologies, aiming to cut national greenhouse gas emissions to between 45 million and 50 million tonnes of CO2 by 2035. "We are significantly increasing investments in promising solutions to reduce power sector and industry emissions, and at the same time, to ensure a reliable and resilient power system," Tan See Leng, Singapore's minister-in-charge of energy, science and technology, said during a parliamentary session on March 2.

At the same time, some Asian countries are deepening their dependence on fossil fuels. According to the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis, China, Japan, South Korea, and Indonesia have all increased coal-fired capacity since 2020 despite decarbonization pledges. In March, when the Philippines declared a national energy crisis, Energy Secretary Sharon Garin said the country planned to boost output from its coal-fired plants to keep energy costs down.

"Be it in Australia, Singapore or Hong Kong, we've seen more focus on safeguarding transition assets and activities than we've seen in Europe," Ghosh says. "That's a reflection of the decarbonization challenges which Asia faces. It's an area of strong income growth, which historically translates to higher emissions….so Asia has to figure out how to meet greater demand for vehicles and air-conditioning, while keeping energy efficiency standards in place."

Wealthier societies, by contrast, are pressing ahead more aggressively with net-zero commitments. The European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), which places a cost on imported carbon-intensive goods, became operational this January. The mechanism matters directly for Asian exporters of goods like steel, aluminium, and cement, who must now account for the carbon intensity of their production to sell into the EU market—a compliance pressure that runs counter to the region's drift back toward coal.

Another global trend—climate change and extreme weather—is pushing public and private investors to direct more capital toward climate adaptation and resilience. This category encompasses projects such as floodgates and dams, smart sensing and early warning systems for climate disasters, and drought-resistant crops.

"A lot of the next ten years of extreme weather conditions are already locked in because of prior emissions," Ghosh explains. On Wednesday, the United Nations said the world has failed to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial times, despite advances in wind and solar power technologies since the Paris Agreement was ratified in 2016.

Last year's record-shattering monsoon season has heightened the urgency to invest in climate resilience. "Large swathes of Asia, including parts of India, China and Southeast Asia, are quite under-insured when it comes to natural disasters," Ghosh says. "That's one of the reasons why there's greater focus in this region on creating greater climate resiliency."

Even if countries appear to be moving backwards on some elements of sustainability—and are increasingly acting alone rather than together—Ghosh still believes the region is heading in the right direction. "The process was always going to be non-linear," he says, yet "we are still moving from a higher-carbon to a lower-carbon economic system over time."

This story was originally featured on Fortune.com.