NewsMacroAndrew Griffith Hits Back at Burnham: My FTSE 100 Experience Means I Know How to Balance the Books

Andrew Griffith Hits Back at Burnham: My FTSE 100 Experience Means I Know How to Balance the Books

Author: City AM Markets·

Key Takeaways

  • •Andrew Griffith was promoted to shadow Chancellor on Monday and was immediately ridiculed by Prime Minister Andy Burnham in the Commons and at PMQs over his Treasury role during the Truss mini-Budget.
  • •Griffith says he was a newly appointed junior minister for financial services regulation and only saw the Budget after it went to print the night before, accusing Burnham of making up stories.
  • •The September 2022 mini-Budget's unfunded tax cuts triggered a fall in the pound and a surge in gilt yields, prompting Bank of England intervention and ending Truss's premiership after 49 days.
  • •Griffith notes that current bond yields are higher than under Truss and above most major economies, attributing this to government uncertainty.
  • •Griffith, a former Sky finance director and qualified accountant, cites his private sector experience as an advantage but rules out detailing policies on stamp duty or the pension triple lock for now.
Andrew Griffith Hits Back at Burnham: My FTSE 100 Experience Means I Know How to Balance the Books

Andrew Griffith's intense interest in politics long predated his entry into it. At the age of 26, he appeared in the audience of a 1997 episode of Question Time, where host David Dimbleby gave him the chance to address the man soon to become Prime Minister, Tony Blair. Griffith did not hold back.

"You may be the glossy smart marketing, but you haven't changed your policies," a bright-eyed Griffith blasted, to chuckles from the crowd.

He might direct the same charge at Andy Burnham today. Yet nearly three decades later, the roles are reversed: it is now the Prime Minister saying unkind things about him.

Within moments of his promotion to shadow Chancellor on Monday, Griffith became the target of repeated ridicule from Burnham – first in the Commons on Tuesday, then again at Prime Minister's Questions on Wednesday – over his service as a Treasury minister during the turbulent, short-lived Liz Truss administration, forever associated with the disastrous mini-Budget.

"What other thing can I say in response to that but God help us," Burnham guffawed.

Griffith rebuffs the attacks, accusing Burnham of "making up stories."

"I was a newly appointed junior minister responsible for financial services regulation – I wasn't sighted on the Budget until it had already gone to print the night before," Griffith said in an interview with City AM.

"Andy Burnham would love to talk about anything other than the fact that, in his few short days in office, he's already writing cheques that the government and bond market feel can't be properly cashed.

"I'm sure he'd like to talk about many other things, including making up stories about [my] influence in a budget, which is simply not the case.

"Clearly mistakes were made, but we need to look forward, not backward."

The mini-Budget, unveiled by then-Chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng in September 2022, announced large unfunded tax cuts that triggered a slide in the pound and a surge in gilt yields, forcing the Bank of England to intervene in the bond market and contributing to Truss's departure after just 49 days in office. Griffith, who was economic secretary to the Treasury at the time, has previously acknowledged that mistakes were made.

Burnham will plainly raise the Truss debacle at every opportunity, but Griffith remains defiant, noting that bond yields – now well above the levels seen under Truss – are higher than in most other major economies, which he attributes to "a function of government uncertainty."

Griffith, who served as an adviser to Boris Johnson before entering the Commons after the 2019 general election, is for now keeping quiet on how a Badenoch budget might take shape. With the Conservatives in opposition after their heavy defeat at the last general election, the party is still working out how to rebuild economic credibility with voters while distancing itself from the Truss era – a balance Griffith will now have to strike as shadow Chancellor.

As a former City minister under Sunak, he is acutely aware of calls for reforms to keep the Square Mile internationally competitive, including the abolition of stamp duty on shares. Would he revisit that? "Not today." A review of the costly state pension triple lock – which some in the Conservative party and the shadow cabinet have described as a "Ponzi system" – also remains firmly off the table.

But Griffith argues that his private sector experience, including a decade-long stint as finance director of Sky, then a FTSE 100 constituent, means he knows how to deliver budgets.

"It reinforces the imperative to tell people, when making decisions, spending money, or cutting taxes, precisely where the money is coming from," said Griffith, a qualified accountant.

"The disciplines that businesses engage in every day, whether hiring people, balancing the books, taking a risk on a new investment, or keeping customers happy by consistently delivering, are all enormously relevant if you are trying to grow your economy [and] keep an eye on what competitor economies are doing."

Griffith views the comparative lack of business acumen in the Cabinet – by one calculation, its members have fewer years of combined private sector experience than he has alone – as a key advantage, one he says is "important politically" in shaping the party's vision for government.

"It's not that one wants a Westminster full of 650 people from business, but given that the productive private sector makes up most of the economy, it would be nice if there were better representation on government benches."