The death of the internet 'built for human eyeballs' is still 'underappreciated' by markets, UBS warns
Key Takeaways
- •UBS says AI agents that act on users' behalf are eroding the internet's assumption of human attention, threatening digital advertising and per-seat subscription software in a shift it describes as moving from business-to-consumer to business-to-agent.
- •BofA analysts estimate that 10% to 40% of subscription payers may not use the products they pay for, identifying the effort required to find and cancel unused subscriptions as the main barrier AI agents could remove.
- •BofA rates about 29% of Bending Spoons' projected 2027 revenue as high risk from AI agents, covering AOL, Eventbrite and Evernote, while assigning medium risk to WeTransfer and low risk to Vimeo.
- •Bending Spoons says it has seen no signs of AI agents driving cancellations, and BofA analysts have not yet observed large-scale effects, estimating annual savings from switching at about $228 to $728.
- •Consumer adoption of AI agents is advancing, with Meta's Muse app reaching an estimated 10 million U.S. downloads in its first 40 days and Instinct reporting that 40% of users connected credit cards to its assistant by week three.

The internet has always run on a single premise: a person is looking at the screen. UBS says artificial intelligence agents that browse, compare and transact on a user's behalf are now breaking that premise — and with it two of the technology industry's most profitable business models.
“Since its inception, the internet has been built for human eyeballs,” Ulrike Hoffmann-Burchardi, chief investment officer for the Americas at UBS Wealth Management, said in a note and podcast released Monday. “Every website, every checkout button, and every software dashboard assumes a person is sitting behind the screen, clicking through tabs.”
Agents that shop, compare and click for a person dissolve that assumption, she argued, striking at digital advertising and at enterprise software sold as a service. Her name for the shift: “We are moving from B2C (business to consumer) to B2A (business to agent).” Her warning to investors: “We believe the speed of AI disruption is still underappreciated by the markets.”
The stakes are plain for any company whose revenue depends on a customer's attention — or lack of it. On the same day, BofA Global Research put numbers on what the shift could mean for one company whose model leans on the second.
Agents don't watch Super Bowl ads
Hoffmann-Burchardi's example looks banal on its face. A shopper tells an agent to find waterproof trail-running shoes under $150 that arrive by Thursday, and the agent checks inventory, compares specifications and completes the purchase.
“AI agents do not have emotions,” she said. “They don't care about a clever Super Bowl spot or a brightly colored retargeting banner.” Brands that want to be found, UBS argues, will need to expose machine-readable product data and real-time inventory, because search-engine optimization alone is no longer enough.
The same logic hits enterprise software. If one AI-augmented employee or an automated workflow can work at the speed of five to 10 people, Hoffmann-Burchardi said, companies do not need to buy more software seats, the per-user subscriptions that underpin the software-as-a-service business model — and if agents talk straight to a database, the dashboard becomes obsolete.
The consumer side is already moving. Meta's Muse agent app passed an estimated 10 million U.S. downloads in its first 40 days, according to Sensor Tower estimates reported in October. UBS also noted that Instinct, a personal-agent app, reported that 40% of users connected their credit cards to its assistant by week three.
The company built on not cancelling
Bending Spoons, the Milan-based company that has bought more than 50 businesses — including AOL, Vimeo, Eventbrite, Evernote and WeTransfer — is close to a pure test of the idea. Its model, as BofA describes it, is to buy durable but under-optimized subscription businesses, cut costs, raise prices and use the cash to buy more.
BofA analysts Omar Dessouky and Ethan Liu built their Nov. 16 report around one line: “Inconvenience is the main moat against AI.” People keep paying, the reasoning goes, because finding the subscription they forgot, researching alternatives or moving years of notes is a chore. An agent does chores.
“Subscribers who derive no value from their subscription have switching costs that are limited to the effort required to identify and cancel the unused subscription – an AI Agent task,” the analysts wrote. Experts they spoke to estimated that “10% to 40% of payers may not use the products they pay for.”
BofA rates about 29% of Bending Spoons' projected 2027 revenue as high risk from AI agents. That covers AOL ($778.8 million in BofA's 2027 estimate), where AI can compare the bundled security add-ons it sells on convenience and AI assistants can replace its tech-help subscriptions; Eventbrite ($403.1 million); and Evernote ($125.5 million), where “AI assistants become a new 'second brain.'” WeTransfer is medium risk. Vimeo is low, because big video libraries are hard to move and AI may get more people making video. BofA has not rated the other 53%.
Bending Spoons says it has not seen this happening. “We closely monitor our businesses' KPIs and haven't seen any signs that AI agents are driving cancellations or switching to alternative products,” a company spokesperson told Fortune.
BofA's analysts largely concur, saying they “have yet to track data to test our hypotheses” and “have not yet seen data to suggest that is currently happening at large scale.” The savings from cancelling AOL, WeTransfer, Evernote, Eventbrite or Vimeo run from about $228 to $728 a year, they wrote — “equivalent to a weekly cup of coffee.” Their preliminary conclusion: “the value gained from switching to cheaper or better solutions rarely exceeds the cost of staying put.”
They also see third-quarter organic growth risks as “skewed mildly to the upside.” BofA rates the stock Underperform, with a $38 price objective against a $41.08 share price, mostly on valuation and on whether Bending Spoons can keep buying companies at its target returns. It carried net debt of 205% of equity at the end of 2025, by BofA's count, and its recent deals include Airtable for $1.285 billion and Miro for $1.355 billion.
Paying not to go to the gym
Economists have measured the moat BofA describes. In a 2006 study of 7,752 health-club members, Stefano DellaVigna and Ulrike Malmendier found that people on monthly contracts paid more than $17 per expected visit when a 10-visit pass would have cost $10 a visit, and that an average of 2.31 months passed between a member's last workout and the cancellation.
Regulators have tried to shrink that moat. The Federal Trade Commission's “click-to-cancel” rule, which would have required cancelling a subscription to be as easy as signing up for one, was vacated by the Eighth Circuit, a federal appeals court, in 2025 on procedural grounds; the agency reopened the rulemaking in March, according to law firm Jones Day.
The eyeball economy has been questioned before. In February 2000, Fortune asked, “How Much Are Your Eyeballs Worth?” Analysts then were valuing internet companies by “market capitalization per pair of eyeballs.” Lycos came out at $244 a pair. “Eyeballs aren't earnings,” the story argued.
UBS cited that story on Monday to make the opposite point: the next visitor may not have eyeballs at all. Bending Spoons reports third-quarter results Nov. 20, the first test since BofA's report of whether its customers are still staying put. The FTC's reopened rulemaking is a second development to watch: the agents BofA describes and the rule the agency wants to revive both aim at the effort of cancelling — the friction that, by BofA's account, keeps unused subscriptions alive.
Generative AI was used for research assistance and/or transcription of this article. The reporter independently reported and verified the factual claims in this article, and a human editor reviewed it before publication.
This story was originally featured on Fortune.com.