NewsCommodities & ForexWhy Falling Oil Prices May Not Deliver the Inflation Relief Many Expect

Why Falling Oil Prices May Not Deliver the Inflation Relief Many Expect

Author: Investinglive·

Key Takeaways

  • •WTI crude oil has dropped back to just below $86 on expectations that Middle East geopolitical tensions are easing.
  • •Since January 2020, US gasoline prices have risen nearly 68%, food costs around 35%, shelter roughly 34%, and overall consumer prices about 31%.
  • •Nominal wages have climbed nearly 34% over the same period, slightly outpacing overall inflation, yet households spending heavily on essentials still feel squeezed.
  • •Falling inflation does not mean prices are declining; it means they continue to rise more slowly, and cheaper fuel could support demand elsewhere and keep some price pressures alive.
  • •For the Federal Reserve, broader improvement in underlying price pressures is key, so markets should monitor core services inflation, wage growth and Treasury yields rather than $5 or $10 moves in oil.
Why Falling Oil Prices May Not Deliver the Inflation Relief Many Expect

WTI crude oil, the West Texas Intermediate grade that serves as the main US oil benchmark, has dropped back to just below $86 amid hopes of easing geopolitical tensions in the Middle East — welcome news for households after this year's energy shock. The Investinglive analysis acknowledges that markets are getting excited about the move, and that the optimism is understandable. Still, it cautions that cheaper oil does not necessarily mean cheaper living, and that the inflation story becomes considerably more complicated once the focus shifts beyond falling crude prices.

In theory, lower oil prices should eventually bring some relief at the gasoline pump, since gasoline is refined directly from crude and is one of the consumer costs most directly tied to the price of oil. Transportation and shipping costs could ease as a result, affording businesses a little more breathing room. But as the analysis asks, when was the last time a rent bill, an insurance premium or a favorite restaurant actually became cheaper? It is precisely there that the inflation story becomes more complicated than falling oil prices alone.

The figures cited in the article underline the point. Since January 2020, gasoline prices in the United States have jumped by nearly 68%, while food costs have risen by around 35% and shelter costs by roughly 34%. Overall consumer prices have increased by approximately 31% over the same period — cumulative gains built up over several years rather than a single year's jump. Nominal wages, meanwhile, have climbed by nearly 34% during that span, slightly outpacing overall inflation, which on paper suggests the average worker should be somewhat better off.

Prices versus purchasing power

The reality is less comfortable, because households do not spend their money the same way. For those devoting a larger share of their income to groceries, rent and gasoline, the cumulative price increases still sting, and a cheaper tank of gasoline today will not magically reverse years of higher living costs. There is also a more fundamental distinction at work: inflation coming down does not mean prices are coming down. It simply means prices are still rising, just more slowly. Even if gasoline prices fall, that does not undo years of increases in housing, food, healthcare and other essential expenses.

And there is another twist to consider. Cheaper fuel leaves consumers with more money to spend elsewhere, potentially supporting demand and keeping some price pressures alive even as energy costs retreat.

What it means for the Fed

For the Federal Reserve, the implications are relatively straightforward, the analysis argues. Falling oil prices can help ease the pressure showing up in headline inflation — the measure that counts food and energy alongside everything else in the consumer basket — but policymakers need to see broader improvements in underlying price pressures before they can feel comfortable changing course on monetary policy.

With that in mind, the piece contends that markets ought to pay closer attention to core services inflation (the component left once volatile food and energy prices are stripped out), along with wage growth and Treasury yields, than to the next $5 or $10 drop in oil prices. If the next inflation reports show genuine signs of cooling beyond energy, markets might then have reason to rethink the Fed's policy outlook. But if services inflation remains stubborn, cheaper oil on its own is unlikely to move the needle much.

The irony, as the analysis concludes, is that oil prices might be falling again, but the inflation problem is not necessarily going to follow in the same direction.

The full analysis is available on Investinglive.